On the 311 Caribbean Cruise, fans got to see three very different shows. As the Carnival Destiny sailed away from Miami, the band played for the whole ship on the lido deck. They also played on the beach at Half Moon Cay in the Bahamas, and each cruiser got to see at least one intimate show in the ship’s Palladium Theatre.

The ever-jovial 311 bassist, P-Nut, appeared to have a blast on stage at all times. But which was his favorite show? We caught up with him after the cruise to find out.

Surprisingly, the lido show might have been my favorite of the cruise as well. I say “surprisingly” because it was cut short by lightning. But in a way, that made it more epic, and the excitement of all the fans sailing away was unmatched the rest of the trip.